News

Abolition of the right to repatriation for Jewish grandchildren

Evgeniy Sokolov
Evgeniy Sokolov Journalist, editor
6 May 2025
2 min. reading time

A bill has been submitted to the Israeli Knesset again aimed at changing the fundamental Law on Return. The initiator was Avi Maoz, the leader of the Orthodox Noam Party, who on April 10, 2025, submitted an amendment proposing to completely revoke the right to repatriation for Jewish grandchildren.

Info
This initiative directly affects the so-called “paragraph on grandchildren” (article 4a), which has been part of the law since 1970, which extends the right to repatriation to the third generation of Jewish descendants. The purpose of the proposed amendment, according to the author, is to “stop non-Jewish aliyah” and preserve the Jewish identity of the state.

Historical context

The current attempt to change the “paragraph on grandchildren” is not the first. Similar initiatives have been put forward before, including in April 2023 by the same Avi Maoz. However, at the time, Prime Minister Netanyahu opposed these changes, saying in an interview with NBC: “This will require careful consideration, I doubt there will be any changes.”

William Daroff, head of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, expressed his opposition to the changes in the law: “The Law of Return is the foundation of Zionism. Our ancestors took the Nuremberg laws and said: if one grandfather or grandmother was enough to kill you, that’s enough to let you in.”

Natalia Meleshko, an expert on repatriation issues, notes: “The paragraph on grandchildren grants an additional right to repatriation not only to Jews and their children, but also to grandchildren up to the third generation. This right is not revoked even if neither of the candidate’s parents is a Halakha Jew.”

Free consultation on digital nomad visa and residence permit
  • We will answer all your questions
  • We will help you choose the best option
  • We will guide you through every step or do everything for you
By submitting this form, you accept our privacy policy.

Political changes in Israel have significantly complicated the repatriation process. According to the RICC Law Center, by the beginning of 2025, there are:

  • Strengthening control measures, including stricter verification of documents;
  • Cancellation of the emergency repatriation program;
  • Domestic political debates on issues of mixed marriages and people with partial Jewish ancestry.
Important
Potential returnees who are eligible for Israeli citizenship through the “paragraph on grandchildren” are strongly advised not to delay the paperwork. If the bill is adopted, the changes will not be retroactive, and the citizenship already obtained will remain valid.
Discuss with the community

By submitting this form, you accept our privacy policy and agree that your personal information will be kept secure and not shared with third parties.